And America Is Lesser for It
Here at 4A Arts, we believe that arts and culture are basic human rights as well as vital components of an active, participatory citizenship; they are essential pieces of America’s heritage and global identity. Trans erasure not only denies Americans access to part of our collective heritage, but strips the trans community of the rights of self-expression and free speech.
Wednesday afternoon, March 29, the legislators of the state of Kentucky voted to override governor Andy Beshear’s veto of Senate Bill 150, effectively outlawing providing support or care for transgender children and minors in the state.
Senate Bill 150 is not just one of the most draconian pieces of anti-trans legislation ever passed. Senate Bill 150 is genocidal.
The United Nations’ 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (the Genocide Convention), ratified by the United States on December 11, 1948, defines genocide as:
[A]ny of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group:
There are some who would argue that the transgender population does not fit any of the categories of nationality, ethnicity, race, or religion. They would be wrong.
The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines “ethnic” as “of or relating to large groups of people classed according to common racial, national, tribal, religious, linguistic, or cultural origin or background” (emphasis added).
No one can deny that the transgender population has a shared cultural background, rich in art and traditions, a culture that is not only distinct from that of conventional America, but has informed and influenced it since the earliest days of European colonization. Spanish conquistador Alvar Núñez Cabeza de Vaca wrote in 1542 about his travels through much of the North American continent – from Florida all the way to Arizona and later down through Mexico – and in his accounts, he described encountering men who married other men, “effeminate men [who] go about covered like women and they perform the tasks of women, and they shoot with a bow, and they carry very great loads.”
In 1652 a court charged Joseph Davis with “putting on women’s apparel and going from house to house in the night time with a female.” And in the late 1660s, French explorer and Jesuit priest Jacques Marquette traveled throughout Illinois, where he described the importance of transgender individuals in the traditions and hierarchy of the Native peoples, a tradition today often known as “two-spirit”:
[S]ome Nadouessi, while still young, assume the garb of women, and retain it throughout their lives. There is some mystery in this, For they never marry and glory in demeaning themselves to do everything that the women do. They go to war, however, but can use only clubs, and not bows and arrows, which are the weapons proper to men…They are summoned to the Councils, and nothing can be decided without their advice. Finally, through their profession of leading an Extraordinary life, they pass for Manitous—That is to say, for Spirits, or persons of Consequence.
By the early 1700s, the tradition of drag had been ignited in the Colonies when Edward Hyde, Lord Cornbury, governor of New York, dressed in imitation of Queen Anne to open the 1702 New York Assembly, responding to critics that he was the Queen’s representative, and sought to represent her faithfully. (Drag and cross-dressing have always overlapped with the trans experience, though the two are not synonymous.)
Revolutionary war hero Casimir Pulaski, commander of the American cavalry during the 1779 siege of Savannah, gave his life in the service of the founding of a new nation of liberty. When a 2019 examination of his skeleton was completed, it was revealed that Pulaski was, in fact, either a trans man or intersex. His monument on Bull Street in Savannah reads “Pulaski, the Heroic Pole, who fell mortally wounded, fighting for American Liberty”.
In fact, one of American history’s most well-known transgender individuals was born in 1886 less than 15 miles away from the Kentucky capitol building where Wednesday’s legislation was passed. Lucy Hicks Anderson was born in 1886 in Waddy, Kentucky; by age 8, the young Lucy was insisting to her parents that she was a girl, not the boy they had assumed. Remarkably for the time, the family doctor encouraged Lucy’s parents to accept and encourage her, and she was raised as a girl from then on.
After marrying her first husband in New Mexico in 1920, Anderson moved to Oxnard, California, where she became known for her hosting and catering skills, becoming a pillar of the community. Anderson earned such a following that not only was her opinion sought in the local newspaper upon the death of President Roosevelt in 1945, but when the Oxnard sheriff jailed her for the illegal sale of liquor, wealthy banker Charles Donlon bailed her out because without her skills, he feared the collapse of his upcoming dinner party. When her gender history was discovered in 1945 as a result of forced testing for venereal disease at Anderson’s brothel, she was charged with impersonating a woman and perjury, for claiming her husband’s military benefits. She defended herself and her marriage to Reuben Anderson in court, responding:
I defy any doctor in the world to prove that I am not a woman. I have lived, dressed, and acted just as I am: a woman. It’s only petty maliciousness that is trying to cause me heartache and harm. If they would devote the same amount of energy to local problems that are hurting the community, it would be much better…I have lived a good citizen for many years in this town, and I am going to die a good citizen, but I am going to die a woman. (Oxnard Press Courier, 1945)
By the 1960s, transgender individuals were putting their unique stamp on mainstream American culture. Virginia Prince, a PhD in Pharmacology who had been cross-dressing since the age of 12, founded the Hose and Heels Club in 1962, later renamed Phi Pi Epsilon to represent the phrase “Full Personality Expression”.
Trans actresses Holly Woodlawn and Candy Darling acted as muse for such household names as Andy Warhol and Lou Reed, whose groundbreaking Billboard hit “Walk on the Wild Side” opens with Woodlawn’s name. Darling was featured in the lyrics of songs by the Rolling Stones, The Velvet Underground, and more and went on to star in the original 1972 stage production of Small Craft Warnings, cast at author Tennessee Williams’s request. Since her early death from lymphoma in 1974 at the age of 29, Darling has been portrayed on stage, screen, and sculpture as a luminary of transgender culture.
Another Warhol muse, Jackie Curtis, is credited with being directly responsible for inspiring the 1970s glam rock movement, later adopted and brought to international prominence by androgynous rock star David Bowie and influencing the style of cult classic film The Rocky Horror Picture Show. Warhol reportedly said that “Jackie Curtis is not a drag queen. Jackie is an artist. A pioneer without a frontier.” By 1984, international superstar Freddie Mercury was making a splash on MTV by wearing a leather miniskirt and a mustache in Queen’s music video for their hit song “I Want to Break Free,” and a few years later he and friends smuggled a cross-dressing Princess Diana into famous gay bar the Royal Vauxhall Tavern. British band Queen is a staple of American music history, having earned its place in American musical annals from the Hollywood Walk of Fame to its 2001 induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in Cleveland, Ohio.
Today, trans artists and creatives are everywhere, from blockbuster director-producer trans twin duo the Wachowskis, who have openly admitted that their 1999 blockbuster hit The Matrix was always a metaphor for the transgender experience, to star Jonathan Van Ness of Netflix’s Queer Eye for the Straight Guy and Getting Curious with Jonathan Van Ness. Elliot Page’s 2021 real-life transition was explored onscreen as a plot point in their character’s journey in The Umbrella Academy.
Any list of contemporary trans artists must include Laverne Cox, best known for her Emmy-award winning role on Orange Is the New Black. Cox was recently the recipient of a new first: Mattel created the Barbie Tribute Collection Laverne Cox Doll, the first Barbie doll inspired by a transgender individual. And Cox isn’t the only gender-bending artist to come to life as a toy: mall staple Build-a-Bear recently announced their latest online exclusive, featuring renowned drag queen RuPaul as a stuffed bear, complete with gold sequined gown and heels.
And this account lacks the time to address the hundreds of trans activists who changed the course of history via protests at such venues as Stonewall, Compton’s Cafeteria, and the Cooper Do-nuts Riot.
The spirit of play, of glamor, and of exploration is the indelible mark that the trans community has left and continues to leave on American culture. Trans culture challenges us to reconsider our relationship to the society around us, and encourages a spirit of transformation and innovation unmatched by any other population. Trans culture demands that we ask ourselves, “Who are we, really?” and emboldens us to answer that question on our own terms rather than be defined by how others would see us. And best of all, trans culture does that by offering us the great gift of creative play.
We cannot deny that anti-trans legislation is specifically designed to impose a single, narrow culture upon the entirety of the American population. Legislative actions that seek to hide trans individuals from sight and deny the next generation access to the lifesaving care they need work to destroy a unique American ethnic group’s identity and existence. The result is an impoverished and anemic American culture, one that sees the world in black and white and denies the existence of all the beautiful and iridescent colors in between.
Kentucky’s Senate Bill 150 is hardly alone; the ACLU and Trans Legislation Tracker report nearly 500 anti-trans bills introduced across the country in 2023 alone. These bills hurt those who need protection the most – our indigenous population, our Black Americans, and our children. And they strip all Americans of the rich gifts that transgender culture has contributed to our country – art forms that, in their expression, are just as fundamental to American culture and development as blue jeans, apple pie, and the wild, wild west.
Arts and culture foster belonging, inclusivity, and empathy, allowing audiences to visualize the lived experiences of others. We call on the arts community to stand with our trans brothers and sisters, to use our shared gifts of communication and connection to uplift and celebrate the unique contributions of this essential and vibrant community.
Anti-trans legislation is not only genocide in its push to extirpate trans individuals from our society; it is cultural genocide – the deliberate erasure of a dynamic and extraordinary culture. And America is lesser for it.
Elena K. Holy is proud to join the 4A movement as General Manager. Her 30+ year arts management career includes NYC’s non-profit Roundabout Theatre Company, commercial Broadway and Off-Broadway at Richard Frankel Productions, and founding and running The Present Theatre Company, where she co-created the New York International Fringe Festival (FringeNYC). FringeNYC was once the largest multi-arts festival in North America – with an all-volunteer staff of 100 people, 2500+ additional volunteers, and 5000 artists representing 200 companies from all over the world, and producing nearly 1100 performances annually, with many now-famous alumni and productions.
As Producer, Holy was awarded the 1997 New York Magazine Award for her “creativity, vision and enterprise”. In 2006, she was named one of New York Magazine’s “Influentials” because she “turned the Fringe Festival, which she founded in 1996, into Sundance for the theater crowd – a place where anyone with an idea and a tiny budget can get noticed. Urinetown, the 1999 Fringe musical that made it to Broadway and won three Tonys, is the most extreme example, but more than a dozen Fringe shows have gone on to significant Off Broadway runs. Her triumph: retaining the fest’s brilliant lunacy amid commercial success.”
Other achievements include the 2007 Mayor’s Award for Arts & Culture, serving as a Tony Awards Nominator from 2008, and being named an Indie Theater Hall of Fame “Person of the Decade” in 2015. As FringeNYC ended (and the pandemic began) she became Interim Managing Director at SHADOWLAND STAGES in beautiful Ellenville, New York where she and husband Kevin share a home with their two westies, Daisy and JuneBug. She serves as Treasurer for the local Chamber of Commerce and is an active member of her community.
Working as the Communications and Marketing Coordinator of 4A Arts fulfills Alex Carrillo’s dream to bring his knowledge of the entertainment industry to the broader arts and culture world. Born in Oakland, CA and raised in the Tri-Cities of Washington state, Alex envisaged himself exiting generational poverty and eventually working in the music industry.
After high school, without scholarships, funding, or other support to help him reach his goals, he enlisted in the U.S. military in 2013, joining the Army Infantry. Alex received his basic training in Fort Benning, Georgia before being stationed in Fort Drum, New York, where he proudly became a member of 4-31 Charlie Company, the Mountain Division (the world’s best kept secret). In 2015, Alex was deployed to Afghanistan in a classified combat war zone through early 2016.
After his time in the service, Alex returned home to seek his college degree. He enrolled at The Los Angeles Recording School, a division of the Los AngelesFilm School, where he received his associate’s degree in Music Production and bachelor’s in Entertainment Business.
While still studying at the L.A. Recording School, Alex landed a publishing deal with Position Music, earning his music a place in the Netflix movie Moxie and in the video game NBA2k22 with his album Locked In.
After receiving his Bachelor’s degree, Alex began working on the business side of the industry, managing artists, performing social and digital marketing, and distribution, among other duties. Alex joined 4A Arts in the summer of 2022, bringing those talents to the nonprofit world.
Whitney S. Christiansen is a native Kentuckian with an interdisciplinary background in arts, education, and advocacy. She spent nearly a decade teaching secondary English and drama in public schools, receiving a master’s in Interdisciplinary Humanities from the University of Louisville in 2017, where she received that year’s Grady Nutt Award for the year’s most creative directed study project, “Summoned,” an interdisciplinary practicum that combined research on medieval morality plays and Marlowe’s Doctor Faustus with contemporary concepts of costume and set design. From 2009-2015 she was a cast member and later director for the Kentucky Highland Renaissance Festival, where she inaugurated and directed the festival’s teen cast, who developed two stage shows in the commedia dell’arte tradition.
Leaving the classroom in 2019, Whitney received her second master’s degree from Colorado State University in Arts Leadership and Cultural Management, where she began working with Be An #ArtsHero, a grassroots campaign dedicated to bringing COVID relief to Arts Workers (now Arts Workers United.) She was the researcher on staff for AWU’s lobbying team for the U.S. House Small Business Committee’s January 2022 hearing on the creative economy, and for Ovation TV’s The Green Room with Nadia Brown, an educational comedy show about the creative economy that launched in March of 2022. Formerly the general manager of the Center for Music Ecosystems, Whitney heads up 4A Arts’ new research initiative alongside her work managing central operations.
Actor, entrepreneur, political strategist, and father of two, Gavin Lodge comes to 4A Arts with a unique perspective on arts and culture in America. A 20-year veteran of stage and screen, Gavin grew up in suburban Colorado and traversed the country in his work with political campaigns at the senate and presidential levels as well as touring for shows.
After studying international affairs and philosophy at the University of Colorado, he worked as a field organizer in the Iowa Caucus followed by the role of “body guy” to then-candidate Senator Maria Cantwell of Washington State. Politics empowered him to move to New York City to pursue a performing career. Ultimately, he performed in multiple Broadway shows (including 42nd Street, Spamalot, and Priscilla, Queen of the Desert) as well as regional theater, national tours and several network television appearances.
Though he was thrilled every time he stepped onto a theatrical or sound stage, Gavin was equally happy to take on leadership roles in his local union and later his kids’ PTA.
With the Covid-19 pandemic, Gavin jumped back into the political realm, working as a strategist for Bryson Gillette, a minority-owned PR firm focused on politics and public affairs. He also volunteered for Be an #ArtsHero, an arts advocacy movement blossoming during the first few months of the pandemic. During his time with Be an #ArtsHero, he was part of a team that successfully lobbied for a first-of-its-kind hearing on the creative economy in front of the House of Representatives Small Business Committee.
Gavin lives in rural Connecticut with his partner (a composer and orchestral conductor), his TikTok-dancing daughter (who is musically gifted in unparalleled ways) and his soccer-playing son who recently told him “Dad? I’m just not into concerts and theater stuff.” As he told his son, Gavin believes there is much more to American arts and culture than “concerts and theater stuff.” From the video games his son loves to play to low-rider paint jobs to streaming television series while sitting on the couch, Gavin sees American arts and culture as an inclusive, “big tent” spectrum where everyone is an artist and everyone is a member of an audience.